Searching or Researching

 In recent discussions of Wikipedia as a tool, a controversial issue has been whether it should be used as a guideline of teaching, or banned altogether as it predominantly is today.  On the one hand, some argue that Wikipedia is a great tool for learning about a certain subject as well as teaching the importance of research and not just searching. The article Search vs. Research brings up the point that Wikipedia can touch upon both of these ideas. Wikipedia is a constant changing source that is able to keep up with changes in history and new information. Though not always factual, this tool can help build a lesson plan for instructors on the importance of researching your source, confirming that what you are writing is in fact from a source that is correct. Research and search as Marc Prensky puts is quite different. Viewing the history of changes on a Wikipedia page and cross referencing important dates and events can secure the credibility of a source. Boyd’s piece on Wikipedia agrees that Wikipedia can be used as a tool that is more than just a source.

      Wikipedia Founder Jimmy Wales argues that students should not cite Wikipedia nor any other encyclopedia for that matter on the same basis of the prior argument. Jimmy Wales in a Business week article from 2005 states that Wikipedia gives a good background knowledge only, and should spark a new idea to research.

      My own Idea is that Wikipedia should be a lesson plan in itself. Learning to write a good research paper and confirming the factual evidence is crucial in a learning environment. I do understand the difficulties of teaching differences of searching and researching but the end product of students being able to decipher and filter through information that is readily available in today’s age is important.  

Advertisements

Author: toyk

I am currently a Special Education major at Western Oregon University. I also work as a direct support personnel for a 15 year old girl with a rare chromosome deletion that falls on the Autism Spectrum. This platform will be used to post ideas and insights, and other resources related to both topics. Cheers!

1 thought on “Searching or Researching”

  1. I agree with what you say that “Wikipedia should be a lesson plan in itself.” It is very true, kids need to learn not only how to write a good research
    paper, but how to back up or detect false information. Great Blog post.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s